go up a chimney down, but cannot go down a chimney up?At first glance, the phrasing seems like impossible nonsense. The trick, however, lies in thinking about the physical state and position of the object in question.The Answer: An umbrella.A closed umbrella can easily be pushed upward through a
Mathematics
Discover more
puzzles
Translation Tools & Resources
Writers Resources
chimney. However, an open umbrella (“down”) cannot be pulled downward through that same narrow space. This riddle teaches a vital lesson: sometimes the answer is hidden entirely in
